Kentucky District Court Issues Good Medicaid and ADA Decision

The Kentucky P&A has received an excellent decision in Michelle P v. Holsinger, No. 3:02-23-JMH (E.D. Ky. Feb. 11, 2005). The case involves Medicaid and ADA challenges to a home and community based waiver waiting list.
 
The court finds the following Medicaid provisions are enforceable pursuant to section 1393: 42 USC 1396a(a)(10)(A) (requiring eligibility); 1396a(a)(10) (B) (requiring comparability); 1396a(a)(8) (requiring reasonable promptness of assistance); 1396n(c)(2)(C) (requiring freedom of choice of institutional or home-based services). The Court applied the federal right enforcement test as "tweaked" by Gonzaga to find that each of these provisions has an unambiguous focus on the individual and contains sufficient rights-creating language. 
 
The Court found the defendant's motion to dismiss the ADA claim was inappropriate for a 12(b)(6) motion: "[S]ince the Plaintiffs do not seek the creation of new programs, whether the relief requested would result in a fundamental alternation 'is a matter that can be resolved only by a careful examination of the facts and circumstances….''" quoting Martin v. Taft, 222 F. Supp. 2d 940, 975 (S.D. Ohio 2002).

Related Content

Medicaid's 56th Anniversary

Medicaid 56th anniversary image

NHeLP has defended Medicaid for over 50 years. This week, we are celebrating the 56th anniversary of Medicaid and recommitting to our efforts to protect and advance health rights for all. Join us in celebration with a donation today! Happy Birthday Medicaid!

DONATE NOW