Ghost Networks: Why Inaccurate Provider Directories Keep Undermining Access to Care

Ghost Networks: Why Inaccurate Provider Directories Keep Undermining Access to Care

For many patients, trying to find a doctor through a health plan’s provider directory can be a daunting experience. Reaching out to these providers may subject a potential patient to endless calls, disconnected numbers, providers who aren’t accepting new patients, or worse—providers who aren’t even in-network despite being listed as such. These aren’t isolated glitches. They are symptoms of a widespread, well‑documented problem known as ghost networks, and they’re undermining access to care in Medicaid managed care, Medicare Advantage, and commercial insurance alike.

Ghost networks are more than an inconvenience. They represent a structural failure that misleads consumers and limits access to care. They also highlight a longstanding lack of oversight by regulators that suggests an inability or unwillingness to enforce network adequacy.

What Are Ghost Networks – and Why Do They Matter?

Ghost networks occur when health plans list providers who are not actually available to treat patients. The reasons include:

  • Providers who claim they never contracted with the plan or are no longer accepting the plan
  • Providers who have moved or no longer work at the listed location
  • Providers who do not accept Medicaid
  • Providers listed with incorrect phone numbers or addresses

A 2026 study of specialty physicians found that 28% of providers participating in Medicaid did not deliver care to Medicaid beneficiaries, with certain specialties having higher rates than others. A 2018 review of Medicare Advantage provider directories found that 48% of location listings contained inaccuracies, with some plans reaching error rates as high as 98%. Numerous secret shopper surveys over the past decade have revealed substantial and persistently high error rates in Medicaid provider directories across most states. These data reports illustrate that the issue of ghost networks has been a problem for a long time.

Ghost networks can cause real harm. Patients waste time trying to reach providers that cannot help them. They get discouraged and may even give up. Coerced billing – when patients cannot find an in‑network provider and must pay out‑of‑network rates – causes financial harm and delayed care. Inaccurate directories can also lead to enrolling in the wrong plan, because consumers may be misled that their providers are in-network when they are not. Ghost networks also disproportionately harm low-income, rural, disabled, and non‑English‑speaking enrollees because there are generally fewer providers serving these populations. In short, their ghost network may be even larger than other enrollees. Compounding the harm to beneficiaries, states have not been very successful enforcing network adequacy standards and access requirements or improving directory accuracy.

What OIG Reports Reveal About Managed Care Provider Networks

Over the last three years, the HHS Office of Inspector General (OIG) has published a series of reports documenting widespread directory inaccuracies, incongruencies, and access barriers in Medicaid managed care and Medicare Advantage networks. Together, they reinforce the pervasive problems with ghost networks but also introduce a different wrinkle that has implications for states’ network accuracy oversight practices.

Maternal Health Networks Have Major Problems – Provider Directories Are Also Inaccurate

In 2026, OIG released two companion reports on maternal health networks. The findings were stark. About 25% of maternal health providers listed in network files plans submitted to CMS told OIG surveyors they were not in-network. Notably, almost half of maternal health providers in network lists were missing from the plans’ public-facing directories. The public directories themselves were also inaccurate: 9% of listed providers were not in-network, 22% of in-network providers were missing, and 33% of listings had inaccurate contact information. Plans provided no accurate phone number for over 25% of providers. These network files are the data states and CMS use to apply time and distance standards, provider enrollee ratios, and other network adequacy standards. If those network lists that CMS reviews are artificially inflated, plans may look like their networks are sufficient when they are, in fact, out of compliance. Even worse, this OIG report suggests that the “real” network – that is, the providers patients could actually search and call through their plan’s public directory – is consistently and meaningfully narrower than the CMS-reviewed network list before you even consider erroneous contact information.

What States Are Doing

Most states rely on quarterly network list updates from the plans as the key component of network adequacy reviews and the plans’ public-facing directories as the main source of information for enrollee access. Federal regulations require plans to assure timely access to services and stipulate that plans must post and regularly update a searchable online directory (with paper copies available on request). States may set specific standards for provider directory accuracy and sanction plans with persistently poor results.

Additionally, states rely on provider directories, plan-submitted network data, and beneficiary complaints as sources of information about network adequacy. Complaints can be important because they often reveal real access barriers that administrative data may miss, including long wait times, inaccurate provider listings, or providers who refuse to accept new patients. Complaints can also help states identify emerging problems before they become widespread. However, complaints alone are insufficient for oversight though as they only capture problems experienced by the relatively small number of people who have the time, knowledge, and determination to report them. Many enrollees never file a complaint, even after encountering significant barriers to care. Some may not know where to complain, while others may give up their search for care entirely after being unable to find a provider. As a result, complaint data often reflect only a fraction of the access problems that actually exist. In addition to relying on complaints, OIG’s investigations into Medicaid managed care maternal health and behavioral health networks found that states can be their own worst enemies when it comes to network oversight. States rarely validate network lists, audit directories, use encounter data to identify inactive providers, enforce penalties for inaccuracies, or set measurable accuracy standards.

The 2024 Medicaid Managed Care Final Rule will require states to establish appointment wait-time standards for routine and urgent visits across a range of provider types, including 10 business days or fewer for routine behavioral health appointments. Additionally, the new rules require states to perform secret shopper surveys of plan networks starting 2028, promptly update directories to correct errors, and develop remedy plans when network adequacy failures are identified. The final rule did not set a specific directory accuracy threshold, though states can set their own compliance benchmark.

How Provider Networks Can Actually Be Improved

Fixing ghost networks will need more than new rules. States, plans, and regulators need to shift their approach to enforcement, data, and accountability. Effective oversight requires states to move beyond reactive toward more proactive monitoring tools.

1. Improve Data Quality and Directory Accuracy

Many ghost networks exist because plans rely on outdated, incomplete, or inconsistent provider information. OIG’s findings repeatedly showed that plans listed providers who were inactive, no longer at a practice location, not accepting new patients, or not even participating in the plan’s network. Federal regulations address these problems by requiring plans to update provider information quarterly. States should establish clear accuracy and timeliness standards on top of federal requirements, rather than relying on periodic or passive updates. These standards could include creating standardized fields – such as whether a provider is accepting new patients, which languages are spoken in the office, accessibility details, and verified practice locations – that would make directories more reliable and more useful. Real-time updates and timely removal of inactive providers within 30 days would prevent directories from becoming stale. Encounter data can help identify providers who have not treated plan members for extended periods, while claims data can help confirm whether providers are actively participating in the network. Over time, initiatives such as CMS’s national provider directory could further improve consistency across payers and reduce duplication of data collection efforts. Changes such as these are necessary because beneficiaries rely on accurate directories not just to find any provider, but to find the right provider for their needs.

2. Strengthen Enforcement

Today, most directory accuracy requirements exist only on paper, and plans face little consequence for publishing inaccurate information. The 2024 Final Rule introduced appointment wait-time standards, secret shopper surveys, and remedy plans. As states incorporate these tools into their contracts and oversight processes, they should build in meaningful enforcement mechanisms. For example, tying capitation payments or performance incentives to directory accuracy would further reinforce accountability. Enforcement matters because without it, plans have no incentive to invest in accurate data systems or to remove inactive providers. When the cost of noncompliance is lower than the cost of fixing the problem, ghost networks persist.

3. Empower Beneficiaries

When directories are wrong, beneficiaries should not bear the financial burden. Providing beneficiaries with the potential of bringing lawsuits against plans would give them recourse when directory inaccuracies cause harm, especially in situations like when a beneficiary faces high medical bills from a provider misidentified as in network. Unfortunately, bringing a lawsuit takes time and money. Policies that require plans to treat inaccurate listings as in-network for billing would protect beneficiaries from surprise bills and coerced out-of-network care. Requiring that the plans reimburse beneficiaries for the medical expenses they incur when they reasonably rely on inaccurate or misleading provider directory information is another option.  These protections will shift the consequences of inaccuracy away from beneficiaries and toward the entities responsible for maintaining accurate information.

4. Reduce Administrative Burden on Providers

Many behavioral health and maternal health providers told OIG they stopped participating in managed care because credentialing, prior authorization, and directory updates were too time-consuming or confusing. Streamlined credentialing processes, unified update portals, and simplified prior authorization requirements would make it easier for providers to participate and accept new Medicaid patients. Better payment rates for behavioral health and maternal health providers would also incentivize providers. Provider participation is the foundation of network adequacy; if providers avoid managed care due to administrative complexity and low payment, managed care plans will struggle to maintain adequate networks, and their incentive to fabricate networks shrink and ghost networks will grow.

Conclusion

Ghost networks are not a minor technical issue – they are a systemic failure that undermines access to care, misleads consumers, and weakens regulatory oversight. OIG’s findings make clear that states’ current approaches are not enough. Particularly as states face major Medicaid cuts due to the so-called One Big Beautiful Bill Act, Medicaid managed care plans will face increasing incentives to narrow their networks further, potentially making the issue of ghost networks worse. Fixing ghost networks will require a commitment to holding plans accountable for the accuracy of the network lists they submit and the provider information they share with enrollees.

Related Content